IndyCar commentator Will Buxton stirred discussions by comparing Scott Dixon’s racing consistency to that of top Formula 1 drivers Fernando Alonso and Lewis Hamilton. On July 6, 2025, Dixon secured victory at the Honda Indy 200 at Mid-Ohio, marking his 21st consecutive season with at least one race win, a feat Buxton described as exceptional within the motorsports world. Buxton’s comparison focused on the idea of “Scott Dixon racing consistency greatness,” inviting fans to reconsider how they evaluate sustained success in racing.
Buxton used statistics involving Formula 1’s two seven-time world champions, Hamilton and Michael Schumacher, to frame his argument. His commentary questioned whether any other racing athlete, including Alonso, matched Dixon’s long-term winning streak and consistency.
Dixon’s Latest Triumph at Mid-Ohio Strengthens His Legacy
Scott Dixon’s win at the 2025 Honda Indy 200 was pivotal not only as his 59th career triumph but also because it extended his record of winning in 21 consecutive seasons. Driving for Chip Ganassi Racing, Dixon edged out teammate and defending champion Alex Palou at the Mid-Ohio circuit, underlining his ongoing dominance in IndyCar racing.
Dixon’s career boasts six IndyCar championships, a prestigious Indianapolis 500 win, and 18 seasons finishing within the top five in overall standings. This level of consistent high performance has set him apart as one of the sport’s all-time greats.
Fan Reactions and Buxton’s Firm Defense of His Position
Buxton’s assertion sparked debate among racing fans, particularly when one user mentioned Fernando Alonso as another driver demonstrating enduring consistency over two decades in Formula 1. Buxton delivered a blunt response:
“Sorry dude but Fernando ain’t even close.”
—Will Buxton, IndyCar Commentator
This comment drew criticism from fans who viewed it as dismissive of Alonso’s achievements. Buxton followed up with a more detailed explanation, comparing Dixon’s 21 consecutive seasons with wins to Hamilton and Schumacher’s 15 consecutive winning seasons in Formula 1, pointing out Alonso’s four-season run as notably shorter.
“Oh 100% in the frying pan. Simply meant close by the metric of winning season on season. Maximum in F1 is Lewis and Michael at 15 consecutive. Fernando’s run was 4. Which isn’t close to 21. Is Alonso insanely talented? Of course. Cross generational greatness. Never in doubt.”
—Will Buxton, IndyCar Commentator
Context on Will Buxton’s Career and Hamilton’s Challenging Season
Will Buxton, a former Formula 1 journalist with the F1TV team for seven years, transitioned to FOX’s IndyCar broadcast booth in 2025. His expertise and commentary have influenced the ongoing conversation about racing excellence, highlighted by his comparisons of Dixon and Hamilton as leading figures in their respective series.
Lewis Hamilton’s 2025 season with Ferrari has been difficult, underscored by the absence of a podium finish at the British Grand Prix—his home race—for the first time in over ten years. This downturn contrasts with Dixon’s unwavering consistency in IndyCar and adds tension to discussions about who stands as the greatest of all time in motorsport.
Broadening the Debate Around Dixon’s Athletic Prowess
Buxton encouraged fans to name athletes across sporting disciplines who demonstrated comparable consistency to Dixon. Several replies mentioned tennis legend Novak Djokovic, NFL icon Tom Brady, and cricket great Sachin Tendulkar. Buxton acknowledged these figures while emphasizing the exceptional nature of Dixon’s accomplishments within racing.
“Some great replies to this. All emphasising the point that shouldn’t just be seen as one the greatest racers of all time, but one of the best athletes in history.”
—Will Buxton, IndyCar Commentator
With IndyCar preparing to head to Iowa Speedway for a double-header weekend from July 11 to 13, the spotlight on Scott Dixon’s remarkable career continues to grow, intensifying the ongoing debate over racing greatness and legacy.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. How much does Scott Dixon get paid?
A. Scott Dixon drives for Chip Ganassi Racing, making around $3.5 million to $4.5 million, which ranks him third in earnings. He joined the team in 2002 and holds the record as the longest-serving driver in their history. With six championships, Dixon is currently the most successful active driver in the IndyCar Series.
